Nexus
by Michael F. Flynn
Consider the man
who is brained by a hammer while on his way to lunch.
Everything about
his perambulation is caused. He walks that route because his favorite café is two blocks distant from his workplace.
He sets forth at the time he does because
it is his lunchtime. He arrives at the fatal point because of the pace at which he walks. There is a reason for
everything that happens.
Likewise, the hammer
that slides down and falls from the roof of the building half a block along. It
strikes with the fatal energy because
of its mass and velocity. It has achieved the terminal velocity because of the acceleration of gravity.
It slid off the roof because of the angle
of the roof, because of the
coefficient of friction of the tiles, because
it was nudged by the toe of the workman, because
the workman too rose to take his lunch, and because
he had arranged his tools where he had. There is a reason for everything that
happens.
Not much of it
is predictable, but who said causes must be predictable?
It would never
occur to you – or at least we hope it would never occur to you – to search out “the
reason” why at the very moment you started your car, some farmer in Shantung
had his foot smashed by his plow-ox. Why should the coincidence become any more
meaningful if your Prius is parked by the field where the farmer plows? Proximity
in space does not add meaning to coincidence in time. Chance is not a cause, no matter how nearby it lurks.
The hammer has a
reason for being there. The diner has a reason for being there. But for the
unhappy congruence of hammer and diner, there is no reason. It is simply the
crossing of two threads in the world-line.
“Ah, what ill
luck,” say the street sweepers as they cleanse the blood and brains from the concrete.
We marvel because our superstitions demand significance from coincidence. The
man was brained by a hammer, for crying out loud! It must mean something! And so poor Fate is made the
scapegoat. Having gotten all tangled up in the threads, we incline to blame the
weaver.
Orphans of Time
I. Loberta Shinbro
The night the
three youths tried to jack his ride, Loberta Shinbro was drinking in a dingy
bar in an unhappy corner of Chicago. But since Shinbro was not himself at that
moment the happiest of men, it was a good fit. He had the morose visage of a
sheepdog whose sheep have inexplicably vanished. It showed in his face, which
was long and narrow and creased with lines at the eyes and lips; and it showed
in his drink, which was both plentiful and potent. He swayed a bit on the bar
stool, ever on the point of toppling over, yet never quite passing it. The
lives of billions had layered on his face and pooled in his eyes. Not even the
bartender tried to engage him in conversation. One was half-frightened of what
the fellow might say. Anger and sorrow are a potent mix; perhaps more potent
than Shinbro’s drink, which was watered in an effort to extend the stock.
The neighborhood
was one of warehouses, wholesalers, terminals and similar establishments, and
the bar’s clientele the usual gallimaufry of pickers, packers, and teamsters peculiar
to such environs. Outside, the night was empty, save for the men at the loading
docks prepping the morning deliveries, and the drifting strangers who
habitually roved empty nights at two in the morning.
From time to
time, Shinbro would glance at the flickering television and mutter something
about “phantoms” but neither the bartender nor the other two patrons asked him
what he meant. Each dwelt introspectively in his own tidy world until Shinbro’s
empty highball glass struck the countertop and he barked, “Another!”
The bartender
did not ask him if he thought he’d had enough, because if he’d thought that he would not have banged the
countertop quite so emphatically. The bartender poured the bar Scotch. Subtleties
of bouquet would be wasted at this point. For the same reason, he watered it
more than usual.
“Shy Hero in
Manhattan!” the television announced as the hour cycled around to a fresh story
in the news-blender. The shout-out tugged momentarily at everyone’s attention,
and on the screen appeared a stolid round-faced woman half-turned from the camera, anxious
to conclude the inescapable interview. A fire. A baby. A dash through the flames.
A rescue! Brief platitudes. Anyone would have done it.
Sure. Maybe. But
“anyone” had not.
“Stupid,” said
the bartender. “She coulda been killed.” But wasn’t that almost a
requirement for heroism? Who is a hero who has never braved danger?
Shinbro
continued to scowl at the screen after the woman’s face had been replaced by promises
of revivified male performance. “I see this woman before,” he muttered, in
accents that proclaimed English an acquired tongue. When the bartender mentioned
the price of the water-and-Scotch, Shinbro glanced at each bill and coin as he
counted out the tab. Not familiar with the local currency, then; an immigrant
and a recent one at that.
“Where’d ya see
her?” the bartender asked, not because he was curious but just to break the
silence.
But his effort
was a match struck on a gusty night. Shinbro said, “Glass water” and from his
inside jacket pocket he pulled a flat tin from which he plucked a lozenge. He swallowed
it, chased with the water. The bartender pretended not to notice. Everyone was
entitled to blaze his own trail to hell, so long as he paid his tab along the
way.
Shinbro took a
deep, shuddering breath. Then, with the air of one spared the headsman’s axe to
keep an urgent appointment on the gallows, he slid from his stool and walked
toward the door. He walked without a stagger, too; and the bartender suddenly wished
he knew what had been in that lozenge. Buzz-B-Gone,
he christened it.
Outside, in the lonely
world of the small hours, Shinbro found three young men trying to gain entry to
his time machine.
#
©Michael F. Flynn 2015Comments? What do you think this story might be about? What has the prologue got to do with it? Why is Shinbro getting drunk?
Perhaps the baby who was saved will grow up to be Hitler 2.0, so Shinbro must steel himself to go back and ensure that he dies (but perhaps chance keeps getting in the way).
ReplyDeleteWhy should the coincidence become any more meaningful if your Prius is parked by the field where the farmer plows?
ReplyDeleteI'm not sure what's meant here by 'meaningful', but couldn't it be possible that the sound startled the ox and/or distracted the farmer?
promises of revivified male performance.
...? What has the woman's actions have to do with 'male performance'? Which males? Where? Why? Is there a competition of some sort? What kind of competition is this? Why is there a competition?
I'm not sure I have enough to go on to speculate about what the prologue has to do with the story. But I'm not sure that 'cause' is always interchangeable with 'reason,' and it's possible that I might get into a 'discussion' with the narrator of the prologue, should I ever meet this person.
What do you think this story might be about?
ReplyDeleteMaybe Shinbro has come back in time in order to see how particular chains of events unfold -- information that he requires for some reason.
What has the prologue got to do with it?
The prologue is essentially a summary of Aristotle's account of chance in the Physics (II c. 5-6). Chance is the incidental congruence of events that are "for the sake of something." The "house-building faculty" of the person who builds a house is the cause in itself of the house; but, say, his musical talents are only an incidental cause. The person possesses the "house-building faculty" for the sake of something, and he possesses musical talents for the sake of something, but the congruence of these two things in the person who built this particular house is incidental (by chance).
Why is Shinbro getting drunk?
I noticed there was a moment where he was seeing "phantoms" when looking at the television -- which, perhaps, he can only see when drunk. Maybe seeing these phantoms is the means by which he can perceive how chains of events unfold -- and, more interestingly, see the congruence of these chains, thus allowing him to "predict" chance events.
Fun. "gallimaufry". I would assume Shinbro knows what's coming down, as a time traveler and all, and it ain't pretty. Perhaps, the 'gallows' means he knows that whatever it is that he must do will not end well for him.
ReplyDeleteAt any rate, I'd read this!
promises of revivified male performance.
ReplyDelete...? What has the woman's actions have to do with 'male performance'?
Late night commercials often tend toward Viagra or some such search for the fountain of youth. Perhaps I need to clarify that the news is breaking for a commercial.
"gallimaufry"
Yes. I said it, and I'm proud.
The prologue is essentially a summary of Aristotle's account of chance in the Physics (II c. 5-6).
Really? What a coincidence! I wonder how that happened? :-)
Really? What a coincidence! I wonder how that happened? :-)
DeleteHa! It's a very nice illustration of the idea, and an awesome way to begin to a story. Makes me really want to read the rest.
Oops. I meant: "...an awesome way to begin a story."
DeleteOh! Oh I see! Oh I'm so sorry--I clearly do not know enough about these things X-D I'm so sorry! I get it now!
ReplyDeleteHelp!
ReplyDeleteCan someone help me with this!
I was arguing all alone on this website, and have been going strong (my user is Lucretius). What should I do in this situation I'm in:
http://outshine-the-sun.blogspot.com/2015/04/estranged-notions-debunking-conspiracy.html#disqus_thread
Christi pax.